I mailed it, got my special reward and today I'm seeing that it's not crossed out so it's definitely bothering me after all that time spent like 45 minutes. It depends where you row your boat. The fish can be found by fishing near the western part of the creek. He will give you the Legendary Fsh Map. How to Catch Legendary Fish First of all you will need to get three special baits from the Bait Shop in near.
Use the Special Lake Lure. The Bait and Tackle store is on the very edge of the lake; it even has a pier leading into the water that you can fish off of. You will need a rowboat to get across which you can find on the outskirts of the swamplands north of Saint-Denis. Map to the Legendary Muskie Longnose Gar You'll find the Legendary in the southern part of the Lagras Swamp. Map to the Legendary Chain Pickerel Sockeye Salmon In the very north western portion of the map in the cold mountainous area you'll find Lake Isabella and the Legendary. You'll head way out into the desert where you had been catching some of the other fish towards the end of the list. You can see the exact location of the fish in the gallery above.
Simply put, players will not catch any Legendary fish without these lures. Not only are they a bit on the expensive side, but, if you fail at catching a legendary fish, back you go to Lemoyne for another special lure. Use the Special River Lure. I even had my own Muskie genocide while frustratingly trying to catch this legendary large mouth bass. These are mostly towards the last few fish, so don't scroll down to those if you don't want some locations to be spoiled.
Map to the Legendary Largemouth Bass That's all of the fish, but there's still more to this whole quest. While catching Legendary Fish is not all that different from regular fishing, there are some important differences. Four islands comprise the area with the jail. This completes the 'Fisher of Fish' questline and awards you with the Special Spinner lure. Legendary Bluegill Location of the Legendary Bluegill The Legendary Bluegill can be caught on the eastern side of the Flat Iron Lake, due west of the city of Rhodes, between the shore and the barrier islands.
Ok, onto the main event. Map to the Legendary Redfin Pickerel Largemouth Bass Finally, the can be found in the San Luis River to the south east of Lake Don Julio and Armadillo. They are also needed to complete the Fish Compendium under the Progress Menu. Only the first 13 legendary fishes are needed for 100%. So you'll need to utilise the four remaining ones to bag these unique, one-off catches. Living in a river, using the Special River Lure increases the chances of catching it. In eagle-eye mode though I have noticed it acting odd.
The only thing I could find about a specific location was one person in this subreddit about two months ago said he got his at the northeast corner of the lake with a Special rive lure instead of the Lake lure. It finally showed up so I guess you can leave the area and it might help or save your game in a different area then reboot your game and go back for the fish. Once they have, Jeremy will send an invite to the hero asking to meet up at his fishing hut. Each one is unique and one-off, so once you've caught each one, it will no longer be available much like the Legendary Animals. A rare type of fish which can be found in lakes and waterways across the map is Legendary Fish. The fish can be caught from the southern shore of the swamp to the northwest of Lakay on the map. This is a sub for Red Dead Redemption 2.
You can get it from the post office, open the Satchel and find it under documents, invitations. Bait is not needed, so do not select any bait to catch them. That's where I had a muskie genocide, I would cast the special Lake Lure out and then reel it in fairly quick so that there would be multiple muskies coming after it. The have already been detailed, showing players where to find the legendary alligator, legendary beaver, legendary cougar, and more. The action doesn't stop there, of course — stop by our to brush up on all the biggest details of Rockstar Games' latest open-world release.
As you say though, bug. Your arduous quest to hook all fourteen legendary creatures is complete. Repeat this every time the fish rests as it will draw the fish in a little faster and give you an edge in each watery duel. Use the Special Lake Lure to catch it. Use the Special River Lure.